When It's Time For a New Start,



When It’s Time for a New Start
Believers® Realty will help you buy or sell your home.

Licensed in the State of Colorado


Featured Listings

Featured Listings





Advice & Tools

Advice & Tools

We are not ashamed of our Christian faith ​and attempt to live up to those standards!

To achieve this goal we work hard, pray and care for others. We choose to live and work by the "Golden Rule" and will make that extra effort to help YOU regardless of your faith.

Not only are we known for our honesty, but we are also known as a Real Estate Company that can get the job done! We are small enough to care about you as an individual; however, we use the latest technologies in the industry to assist you in all of your real estate needs. As a result, your needs will be met quickly, at the best value, and with the least inconvenience!

Please contact us if we can be of assistance in buying or selling your home. We are eager to serve you today!

On our site you have the ability to SEARCH PROPERTIES in Pueblo, Pueblo West, and the surrounding Southern Colorado area including, Rye, Colorado City, Avondale, Beulah, Walsenburg and the San Isabel area. If you have seen one of our signs on a property that we have listed you can also view our Featured Properties. We can show you any property on the market for sale that is listed through our Multiple Listing Service.

Take a look at our ADVICE & TOOLS page where you will find a MORTGAGE CALCULATOR, which evaluates not only your payment, interest, how much you have to earn to qualify for a particular piece of property, how quickly you can pay down a mortgage with additional payments. We also have information on the buying and selling process, home shopping tips and more.

If you are new to the area take a look at the RESOURCE page. There you will find local points of interest as well as useful information about the great area we live in.

If you are interested in selling your property we would be more than happy to give you a comprehensive evaluation of your home, land, multi-family or commercial property and explain all the ways that we can help you get the most out of your property and give you a complete presentation on how we market our listings.

So make Believers® Realty your one stop shop for all your Real Estate needs.


Believers Realty, Inc

Patti Jo Brown

In May of 2014 we listed our home of twenty years located in Pueblo West, Colorado, with Mary Highline of Believers® Realty. Our house was listed on a Friday and by Wednesday of the following week we had multiple offers. With Mary and the help of her professional staff we sold our house in eight days! Mary was also very instrumental in helping us to buy a 1.3 acre lot in order to build our new home. I HIGHLY recommend Mary Highline and her staff for all of your realtor needs. You will not be disappointed.

Believers Realty, Inc

Ian Miller

Mary from Believers® Realty is a trustworthy and knowledgeable person. She helped my family during a tough time when we had to sell my mother’s home. She listed, showed and sold her home in less than one month. Mary is simply amazing.

Believers Realty, Inc

Martin Greenwood

We sold our house in eight days listing it with Believers® Realty. Mary and her staff are extremely knowledgeable regarding market value, loan information, and buyer and seller needs.

Believers Realty, Inc

Brian Sheet

Believers® Realty was very professional and proactive about the approach in which they were able to sell my real estate for me. Mary and her daughter Sandy were very diligent in following up on all potential buyers until my property was sold. I would recommend Believers® Realty to anyone who is trying to sell their property.

Believers Realty, Inc

Bobby White

I would highly recommend Mary from Believers® Realty to my friends, family or anyone looking for a real estate agent. She is very knowledgeable and responsive to my questions or concerns. She is the best Realtor I have ever worked with.

Believers Realty, Inc

Sherri the Salsa Dancer

After working with several other realtors in the Pueblo area, Mary stood out right away. From the very first phone call, she was not only responsive, caring, knowledgeable, and professional, but most importantly, she was willing to rearrange her schedule to show me a property the next day, when others didn't even return my calls for days. Mary and her family-run office staff were personable and always dependable, making me feel that I was their highest priority. Her work ethic is outstanding. Mary worked very hard to help me find my dream home and negotiate a great price for it. It took a long time to find the right home, but she persevered even when I was ready to give up. When I finally found my dream home, Mary helped me negotiate a great price. I'm so excited about my new home, and I can't wait to hire Mary again for my next real estate purchase. I cannot recommend her highly enough. She's the best.


Believers® Realty, Inc
1300 N Elizabeth Street,
Pueblo, CO 81003



Navica MLS System
Equal Housing Opportunity
Colorado Association of Realtors
Navica MLS System